When Cathy Rigby opened in the Broadway production on Peter Pan, The Boston Glove proclaimed, "Cathy Rigby is remarkably talented... she sings wonderfully, with precision, with range, with style... she is irresistible. Rigby will lift you out of your seat!"Cathy Rigby garnered rave reviews and set box office records when she starred in the 35th Anniversary production of Peter Pan on Broadway in 1991. She earned two Tony Award nomincations: one for Best Actress in a Musical and another for Best Revival.